Ok, so I think I’ve finally hashed out a grading rubric for webcomics, and I think I will base it off my criteria of the three things that make a webcomic successful (i.e. art, writing, and updating). I will rate each of these on a scale of 1-5 and then I will also add in my personal overall gut feel of the story on a 1-5 scale and then add them all up for the final tally.
This will be my grading sheet/ format –
Summary of comic and plot along with any other pertinent information:
Art:
A score of 5 is a comic with outstanding jaw dropping art that has both a unique and interesting style. The style or tone of the art must also much the atmosphere of the comic. 4s and bellow will not meet that criteria by degrading degrees.
Writing:
A score of 5 signifies an artist who not only pays attention to the mechanics of writing (the grammar and spelling), but their story ideas and/ or jokes are original. This also means the characters voices (not just their appearance) and personalities must be unique. The plot must flow well together. It will use very few clichés.
Updating:
A score of 5 means a comic promises that it will stick to a certain update schedule and they keep their word. A five also means the update schedule is concurrent with the difficulty of the art style. Meaning a for panel comic will take less time to draw then a giant, sepia colored painting. I know life happens but promises are promises. Extra points for artists who let their audience know they will be missing an update or be tardy.
Overall impression:
This the most subjective of all the categories but being subjective isn’t a bad thing. I insist that being purely objective is impossible and webcomics aren’t about being subjective anyways. A score of 5 means I just loved the comic, it made me laugh, it made me want more.
Why would I post this? Well I am going to start reviewing webcomics that way, you my dear friends, will know which ones are worth your time and are your type of webcomic. I will start organizing my “webcomic links” section of this site according to the score they receive. If you don’t agree with my critique of a certain webcomic please let me know!